|
| Enumeration of Stellations |
This page contains results obtained using
Great Stella.
The question is: how many stellations are there of the Platonic solids, the
Archimedean solids, and their duals? For some models the result remains
unknown, because the time taken to calculate the result would be too long. For
these models the number of stellations is always over one trillion (a very long
way over).
Two criteria are of interest here.
Fully supported stellations and
Miller's rules.
For fully supported stellations, the previously highest count obtained
was for the pentagonal icositetrahedron, with
72621 stellations, discovered by Peter Messer. All results higher than that
are previously unpublished. The highest result obtained so far using Stella is
for the pentagonal hexecontahedron, with over
30 trillion fully supported stellations. It took several months to
compute on an Intel i5 2.5 GHz computer, counting over a million stellations
counted per second.
For Miller's rules, the previously highest count was obtained was for the
rhombic triacontahedron. It was enumerated by John
Gingrich and mentioned only in a paper by Peter Messer (reference [17] in
my paper). John designed a ciruit
board specifically for the job. The result was calculated
correctly, but a misunderstanding over
Miller's 5th rule meant the final figure given
was not quite right. I have been in contact with John Gingrich and we both
agree that the figure of 358833098 calculated by Stella in the table below is
the correct one. The largest result achieved with Stella so far is for the
truncated dodecahedron with 2645087084526 stellations
using Miller's rules. Compare this result with the number of fully supported
stellations for the same model, a mere 1141, and you can see the huge
difference between these criteria!
Notes:
- "*" lines represent duals of the model in the preceding line.
- Total numbers are followed in brackets by the number of
reflexible, and then the number of chiral, for both cell types
and stellations.
- My results include the core as a cell type and as a stellation.
- All stellations are included, even when they do not make use of all
the facial planes of the original polyhedron. For example, the cube
would be included as a stellation of the cuboctahedron. This is
something I should probably fix sometime. For
isohedral models, it makes no
difference though, and these are generally the ones of most interest.
- The "Max Cells per Layer" column shows the maximum number of cell
types which occur in any single layer. Here a pair of chiral cells is
counted as two.
- Question marks show where I haven't been able to get an answer
yet, and probably never will using the current algorithm.
- The "pseudo" models are ones where the vertices are only "locally"
uniform, but a "cap" is twisted. They turn out to have prism symmetry.
Platonic and Archimedean Solids |
Vertex Desc | #Layers | #Cell types (reflexible, chiral) | Max Cells per Layer | #Stellations - Fully supported (reflexible, chiral) | #Stellations - Miller's rules (reflexible, chiral) |
3.3.3 | 1 | 1 (1, 0) | 1 | 1 (1, 0) | 1 (1, 0) |
4.4.4 | 1 | 1 (1, 0) | 1 | 1 (1, 0) | 1 (1, 0) |
3.3.3.3 | 2 | 2 (2, 0) | 1 | 2 (2, 0) | 2 (2, 0) |
5.5.5 | 4 | 4 (4, 0) | 1 | 4 (4, 0) | 4 (4, 0) |
3.3.3.3.3 | 8 | 11 (10, 1) | 3 | 18 (16, 2) | 59 (32, 27) |
6.6.3 | 3 | 4 (4, 0) | 2 | 6 (6, 0) | 10 (10, 0) |
* | 6 | 9 (7, 2) | 3 | 21 (17, 4) | 188 (52, 136) |
4.3.4.3 | 5 | 8 (8, 0) | 2 | 13 (13, 0) | 21 (21, 0) |
* | 4 | 4 (4, 0) | 1 | 4 (4, 0) | 5 (5, 0) |
4.6.6 | 5 | 9 (9, 0) | 2 | 18 (18, 0) | 45 (45, 0) |
* | 10 | 31 (18, 13) | 8 | 1762 (372, 1390) | 143383367876 (3642866, 143379725010) |
8.8.3 | 5 | 9 (9, 0) | 2 | 18 (18, 0) | 45 (45, 0) |
* | 10 | 32 (19, 13) | 9 | 3083 (565, 2518) | 218044256331 (3645883, 218040610448) |
4.4.3.4 | 11 | 48 (31, 17) | 10 | 18827 (3339, 15488) | ? (128723453647, ?) |
* | 10 | 32 (19, 13) | 7 | 1201 (386, 815) | 253811894971 (4060051, 253807834920) |
Pseudo 4.4.3.4 | 13 | 132 (44,
88) | 31 | 28613467776022 (193594720, 28613274181302) | ? (?, ?) |
Pseudo * | 12 | 88 (26, 62) | 23 | 5713528508 (1764087, 5711764421) | ? (?, ?) |
8.4.6 | 11 | 49 (32, 17) | 11 | 22632 (3254, 19378) | ? (317650001638, ?) |
* | 23 | 292 (74, 218) | 38 | ? (14728897413, ?) | ? (?, ?) |
4.3.3.3.3 | 20 | 274 (0, 274) | 26 | 299050957776 (18, 299050957758) | ? (?, ?) |
* | 12 | 69 (0, 69) | 10 | 72621 (0, 72621) | ? (0, ?) |
5.3.5.3 | 14 | 41 (32, 9) | 7 | 847 (432, 415) | 70841855109 (7071672, 70834783437) |
* | 13 | 29 (20, 9) | 5 | 227 (115, 112) | 358833098 (84959, 358748139) |
5.6.6 | 14 | 45 (35, 10) | 7 | 1117
(579, 538) | 3082649548558 (162782259, 3082486766299) |
* | 29 | 253 (93, 160) | 26 | 71112946668 (20687415, 71092259253) | ? (?, ?) |
10.10.3 | 14 | 45 (35, 10) | 7 | 1141 (600, 541) | 2645087084526 (128761995, 2644958322531) |
* | 29 | 241 (89, 152) | 24 | 13902332663 (8809989, 13893522674) | ? (?, ?) |
5.4.3.4 | 29 | 273 (124, 149) | 27 | 298832037395 (133925171, 298698112224) | ? (?, ?) |
* | 29 | 226 (83, 143) | 23 | 7146284014 (6446491, 7139837523) | ? (?, ?) |
10.4.6 | 29 | 294 (130, 164) | 29 | 1016992138164 (226575482, 1016765562682) | ? (?, ?) |
* | 59 | 2033 (342, 1691) | 108 | ? (>10^12, ?) | ? (?, ?) |
5.3.3.3.3 | 47 | 1940 (0, 1940) | 68 | ? (579, ?) | ? (?, ?) |
* | 32 | 536 (0, 536) | 29 | 30049378413796 (0, 30049378413796) | ? (0, ?) |
Prisms and Antiprisms |
Vertex Desc | #Layers | #Cell types (reflexible, chiral) | Max Cells per Layer | #Stellations - Fully supported (reflexible, chiral) | #Stellations - Miller's rules (reflexible, chiral) |
3.4.4 | 1 | 1 (1, 0) | 1 | 1 (1, 0) | 1 (1, 0) |
* | 2 | 2 (2, 0) | 1 | 2 (2, 0) | 2 (2, 0) |
5 or 6.4.4 | 2 | 2 (2, 0) | 1 | 2 (2, 0) | 3 (3, 0) |
* | 4 | 6 (5, 1) | 3 | 11 (9, 2) | 25 (16, 9) |
7 or 8.4.4 | 3 | 3 (3, 0) | 1 | 3 (3, 0) | 6 (6, 0) |
* | 6 | 12 (9, 3) | 5 | 53 (34, 19) | 884 (135, 749) |
9 or 10.4.4 | 4 | 4 (4, 0) | 1 | 4 (4, 0) | 10 (10, 0) |
* | 8 | 20 (14, 6) | 7 | 260 (125, 135) | 299225 (2131, 297094) |
11 or 12.4.4 | 5 | 5 (5, 0) | 1 | 5 (5, 0) | 15 (15, 0) |
* | 10 | 30 (20, 10) | 9 | 1324 (461, 863) | 956478162 (81336, 956396826) |
4.3.3.3 | 4 | 7 (5, 2) | 3 | 20 (12, 8) | 78 (36, 42) |
* | 3 | 4 (3, 1) | 3 | 7 (5, 2) | 10 (7, 3) |
5.3.3.3 | 5 | 9 (7, 2) | 4 | 30 (20, 10) | 218 (79, 139) |
* | 3 | 4 (3, 1) | 3 | 7 (5, 2) | 10 (7, 3) |
6.3.3.3 | 6 | 15 (10, 5) | 5 | 161 (71, 90) | 21695 (1004, 20691) |
* | 5 | 9 (6, 3) | 5 | 36 (19, 17) | 123 (50, 73) |
7.3.3.3 | 7 | 17 (12, 5) | 6 | 216 (105, 111) | 64746 (1969, 62777) |
* | 5 | 9 (6, 3) | 5 | 36 (19, 17) | 123 (50, 73) |
8.3.3.3 | 8 | 25 (16, 9) | 7 | 1079 (356, 723) | 59430630 (67797, 59362833) |
* | 7 | 16 (10, 6) | 7 | 179 (69, 110) | 9822 (542, 9280) |
9.3.3.3 | 9 | 27 (18, 9) | 8 | 1359 (488, 871) | 180914190 (128818, 180785372) |
* | 7 | 16 (10, 6) | 7 | 179 (69, 110) | 9822 (542, 9280) |
10.3.3.3 | 10 | 37 (23, 14) | 9 | 6626 (1587, 5039) | 1381889260340 (13187809, 1381876072531) |
* | 9 | 25 (15, 10) | 9 | 916 (251, 665) | 10730395 (12907, 10717488) |
11.3.3.3 | 11 | 39 (25, 14) | 10 | 8055 (2081, 5974) | ? (24916982, ?) |
* | 9 | 25 (15, 10) | 9 | 916 (251, 665) | 10730395 (12907, 10717488) |
12.3.3.3 | 12 | 51 (31, 20) | 11 | 39714 (6683, 33031) | ? (7662769412, ?) |
* | 11 | 36 (21, 15) | 11 | 4836 (923, 3913) | 86516934850 (793961, 86516140889) |
|